Susan Collins: The Vanished Waitress Mystery

Susan Collins

'The Disappearance of Susan Collins: A Small Town’s Darkest Secret'

'She was the kind of girl who lit up a room—until the night she vanished without a trace.'

The Last Seen

On the evening of October 12, 1998, 22-year-old Susan Collins left her waitressing job at Maggie’s Diner in the quiet town of Cedar Falls, Iowa. She told her co-workers she was meeting someone but didn’t say who. Witnesses reported seeing her blue ’94 Honda Civic parked near the old railroad tracks on the outskirts of town—an area locals called 'Lover’s Lane.'

By midnight, Susan hadn’t returned home. Her worried mother, Linda Collins, reported her missing the next morning. When police searched the area near the railroad tracks, they found Susan’s car—unlocked, keys still in the ignition, her purse and phone left inside. But Susan? Gone.

The Suspects

With no signs of a struggle, detectives initially wondered if Susan had left willingly. But her family insisted she wouldn’t abandon her life without a word.

The Ex-Boyfriend – Mark Reynolds
Susan had recently broken up with Mark, a mechanic with a temper. Witnesses said he’d been drinking at a bar the night she vanished, but his alibi was shaky. When questioned, he claimed he was home alone.

The Mysterious Stranger – 'Jeremy'
Susan’s best friend, Rachel, told police Susan had been talking to a man named Jeremy online. No last name, no photo—just cryptic chat logs about meeting in person. Police traced the account to a cyber café, but the trail went cold.

The Local Outcast – Roy Dawson
A drifter with a record for petty crimes, Roy was known to lurk near the railroad tracks. A gas station clerk claimed he’d seen Roy that night, covered in dirt, muttering to himself. But without physical evidence, police couldn’t hold him.

The Chilling Clue

A month after Susan vanished, a hunter found a single sneaker—size 7, matching Susan’s—in the woods five miles from her car. Nearby, a rusted pocketknife with traces of blood was discovered. DNA tests confirmed the blood was Susan’s.

But the knife was too corroded for fingerprints.

The Theories

Was it a crime of passion? Mark had no alibi, and Susan’s friends said he was possessive.

Was she lured by an online predator? 'Jeremy' was never identified.

Did Roy Dawson see something—or do something—that night? He died in a drunk driving accident two years later, taking his secrets to the grave.

The Unsolved Mystery

Despite decades of investigations, Susan Collins was never found. Some believe she’s buried in the dense forests surrounding Cedar Falls. Others think she was taken far away.

Her mother, Linda, still leaves the porch light on every night—just in case Susan ever comes home.

'If you know anything about Susan Collins’ disappearance, call the Cedar Falls Tip Line: 555-7890. A $50,000 reward remains unclaimed.'

(This story is fictional but inspired by real unsolved cases.)

Would you like a deeper dive into any part of the mystery? A suspect profile, an alternate ending, or even a 'break in the case'? Let me know!

Susan Collins: The Vanished Waitress Mystery

Report Page