Sarah Sherman's Disappearance and the Spike Killer

Sarah Sherman

Title: 'The Disappearance of Sarah Sherman: A Small Town’s Darkest Secret'

Prologue: A Vanishing Act
On the evening of October 12, 2018, 24-year-old Sarah Sherman left her waitressing job at Benny’s Diner in the quiet town of Millfield, Ohio. She texted her roommate, 'Be home soon – picking up snacks!' But Sarah never made it home. Her car was found the next morning, abandoned near the edge of Blackwood Forest, keys still in the ignition, purse on the seat. There was no sign of a struggle—just a half-empty pack of cigarettes and a receipt from a gas station two miles away.

Chapter 1: The Girl Next Door
Sarah was well-liked—a bright, artistic soul who dreamed of moving to Chicago to pursue photography. She had no known enemies, no volatile exes, no history of running away. But as detectives dug deeper, they uncovered whispers of a darker side to Millfield.

A local mechanic, Greg Harlow, claimed he saw Sarah arguing with an unidentified man outside the gas station that night. Another witness, a high school senior, reported seeing a dark pickup truck speeding toward the forest around the same time Sarah vanished. But with no security footage and only vague descriptions, leads went cold.

Chapter 2: Secrets in the Soil
Months passed with no breakthroughs—until a hunter stumbled upon a shallow grave just five miles from where Sarah’s car was found. The remains were badly decomposed, but dental records confirmed it was her. The coroner ruled blunt force trauma as the cause of death, and a single, cryptic clue was found with the body: a rusted railroad spike, placed deliberately near her skull.

Rumors swirled. Some pointed to a local railroad worker with a violent past. Others whispered about an old Millfield legend—the 'Spike Killer,' a boogeyman tale from the 1970s about a man who left railroad spikes near his victims. But was it just a sick coincidence, or had a dormant killer resurfaced?

Chapter 3: A Twisted Confession
In 2021, a break came from an unlikely source. Convicted felon Dale Mercer, serving time for an unrelated assault, claimed his cellmate had bragged about killing Sarah. According to Mercer, the man—a trucker named Vince Colter—had ties to Millfield and a fascination with 'marking' his crimes.

Detectives tracked down Colter, now living in Nevada. When questioned, he smirked and said, 'Prove it.' With no physical evidence linking him to Sarah, the case stalled—until a search of his old property uncovered a disturbing collection of railroad memorabilia, including spikes matching the one found with Sarah’s body.

Epilogue: Justice or Just a Story?
Despite the circumstantial evidence, prosecutors couldn’t secure an indictment. Sarah’s family still fights for answers, while some in Millfield believe the real killer is still out there. Was Vince Colter a calculating murderer, or just a twisted man playing games? And why did Sarah Sherman have to die?

To this day, her case remains open—a haunting reminder that even in the sleepiest towns, evil can hide in plain sight.

🚨 Case Details:

Victim: Sarah Sherman (24, waitress/photographer)

Last Seen: October 12, 2018, Millfield, OH

Cause of Death: Blunt force trauma

Key Suspect: Vince Colter (alleged connection to 'Spike Killer' lore)

Status: Unsolved

'Some say the forest keeps its secrets. Sarah’s might still be buried there.' 🌲🔍

Sarah Sherman's Disappearance and the Spike Killer

Report Page