Danny Serafini: From Baseball to Murder

Danny Serafini

'The Broken Pitch: The Danny Serafini Story'

Prologue: The Golden Arm
In the mid-1990s, Danny Serafini was a rising star in Major League Baseball. A left-handed pitcher with a wicked curveball, he was drafted by the Minnesota Twins in 1992 and made his MLB debut in 1996 at just 22 years old. By 1997, he was traded to the Chicago Cubs, where he showed flashes of brilliance. But injuries and inconsistency derailed his career, and by 2000, he was out of the majors.

For years, Serafini bounced around the minors, independent leagues, and even played in Mexico and Japan, chasing the dream that had once seemed so certain. Then, in 2007, his name resurfaced—but not for a comeback.

Chapter 1: A Dark Turn

On June 25, 2007, in the quiet, affluent community of Homewood, California, a 911 call shattered the early morning calm. Inside a lakeside mansion, 70-year-old Robert Gary Spohr, a former professional golfer, lay dead from a single gunshot wound to the head. His 68-year-old wife, Wendy Wood Spohr, was critically injured with a gunshot to the chest. She would die weeks later in the hospital.

The couple’s 9-year-old granddaughter was home at the time but unharmed. She told investigators she had seen a masked intruder.

At first, police suspected a home invasion. But the crime scene didn’t add up—nothing was stolen, and the attack seemed targeted. Detectives soon learned that the Spohrs’ daughter, Erin Spohr-Nass, was married to Danny Serafini’s cousin, former MLB pitcher Jason Grimsley.

The connection raised eyebrows.

Chapter 2: The Fallen Star

By 2007, Serafini’s baseball career was long over. He had struggled with financial troubles and legal issues, including a DUI arrest in 2005. But was he desperate enough to kill?

Investigators dug deeper and discovered Serafini had a motive: money. The Spohrs had reportedly cut off financial support to their daughter and son-in-law, Grimsley, after his 2006 arrest in a steroid scandal. Some speculated Serafini—who was close to Grimsley—may have been enlisted to 'solve' the problem.

But for years, the case went cold.

Chapter 3: The Break

In 2021, advances in DNA technology led to a shocking breakthrough. Forensic evidence from the crime scene—including a glove left behind—was linked to Serafini and another man: 57-year-old Scott Alan Barker, a former professional wrestler and acquaintance of Serafini’s.

On October 19, 2021, Serafini was arrested in Nevada. Barker was arrested in Idaho. Both were charged with first-degree murder.

Chapter 4: The Trial

Prosecutors alleged Serafini and Barker meticulously planned the murders, with Serafini acting as the inside man due to his family connection. The motive? A $1 million inheritance that would eventually go to Erin Spohr-Nass—money Serafini allegedly believed he could access through Grimsley.

In 2023, Serafini pleaded not guilty, maintaining his innocence. But the evidence against him was damning:

DNA on the glove matched both suspects.

Cell phone records placed Serafini near the crime scene.

Financial records showed he was in dire straits before the murders.

As of 2024, the case remains ongoing, with Serafini awaiting trial.

Epilogue: From the Mound to Murder
Danny Serafini’s story is a tragic fall from grace—a once-promising athlete now facing life in prison. Was he a desperate man manipulated by circumstance, or a cold-blooded killer who thought he could outsmart the law?

The trial may finally provide answers—but for the Spohr family, justice has already been 17 years in the making.

Case Status: Pending trial as of 2024.

Would you like any additional details or a deeper dive into a specific aspect of the case?

Danny Serafini: From Baseball to Murder

Report Page