Understanding Flutter's Refresh Cycle: Hot Reload vs Hot Restart vs Full Rebuild

This article was translated specially for the channel FlutterPulseYou'll find lots of interesting things related to Flutter on this channel. Don't hesitate to subscribe!🚀

When developing Flutter applications, one of the framework's most celebrated features is its fast development cycle. However, many…

When developing Flutter applications, one of the framework's most celebrated features is its fast development cycle. However, many developers — especially those new to Flutter — often misunderstand the differences between Hot Reload, Hot Restart, and completely rebuilding an app. This knowledge gap can lead to frustration when code changes don't appear as expected or when state behaves unpredictably.

In this article, we'll explore the technical differences between these refresh methods, when to use each one, and how they impact your development workflow.

Hot Reload: The Speed Champion

Hot Reload is Flutter's crown jewel for rapid development. When you trigger a Hot Reload (typically by pressing the lightning bolt icon ⚡ in your IDE or typing r in the console), here's what happens behind the scenes:

// Before change
Widget build(BuildContext context) {
  return Container(
    color: Colors.blue,
    child: Text('Hello World'),
  );
}

// After change
Widget build(BuildContext context) {
  return Container(
    color: Colors.red, // Changed blue to red
    child: Text('Hello Flutter'),  // Changed text
  );
}

When you Hot Reload this change:

1. The Dart VM injects your updated code into the running app
2. The framework automatically rebuilds the widget tree
3. Your UI updates to reflect the changes
4. Crucially, your app's state is preserved

Key Benefits:

• Lightning-fast feedback (typically under 1 second)
• State preservation (navigation position, form inputs, scroll position)
• Minimal disruption to your testing flow

Limitations:

Hot Reload cannot apply all types of changes:

• Class structure modifications
• Global variable changes
• Enum additions or modifications
• Constructor changes
• Changes to the main() method

Hot Restart: The Middle Ground

When Hot Reload isn't enough, Hot Restart offers a middle ground. Triggered by pressing the restart icon 🔄 in your IDE or typing R in the console, Hot Restart:

1. Completely recompiles your Dart code
2. Restarts your app from scratch
3. Resets all state to initial values

// Adding a new class or changing class structure
class UserModel {
  final String name;
  final int age;  // Added a new field

  UserModel(this.name, this.age);  // Changed constructor
}

For changes like these, Hot Restart is necessary.

Key Benefits:

• Moderately fast (typically a few seconds)
• Applies more extensive changes than Hot Reload
• Clean state for testing initialization logic

When to Use:

• After changing class structures
• When modifying state management logic
• After adding/removing global variables
• When you need to test your app from its initial state

Full Rebuild: The Complete Reset

Sometimes, only a full rebuild will do. This involves stopping your app (pressing the stop button ⏹️), then starting it again. During this process:

1. Your app is completely terminated
2. Both native and Dart code are recompiled
3. The app is reinstalled and launched from scratch

Key Benefits:

• Applies all possible changes, including native code and dependencies
• Provides the most accurate representation of how your app will behave in production
• Resolves deep-seated issues that persist through Hot Restart

When It's Necessary:

• After modifying pubspec.yaml (adding/removing packages)
• When changing native code (iOS/Android)
• After adding/modifying assets
• When updating plugin configurations
• After changing build configurations

# Changes to pubspec.yaml require a full rebuild
dependencies:
  flutter:
    sdk: flutter
  http: ^0.13.5  # Added new package

Comparison: When to Use Each Method

| Feature | Hot Reload | Hot Restart | Full Rebuild |

| — — — — -| — — — — — — | — — — — — — -| — — — — — — — |

| Speed | Fastest (<1 second) | Moderate (few seconds) | Slowest (tens of seconds to minutes) |

| State Preservation | ✅ Preserved | ❌ Reset | ❌ Reset |

| Dart Code Changes | Partial | Complete | Complete |

| Native Code Changes | ❌ Not Applied | ❌ Not Applied | ✅ Applied |

| Package/Asset Changes | ❌ Not Applied | ❌ Not Applied | ✅ Applied |

| Use Case | UI tweaks, method implementation changes | Class structure changes, state logic updates | Package changes, native code updates |

Debugging Common Issues

When Hot Reload Seems to Do Nothing

If your changes don't appear after a Hot Reload, consider:

1. Widget tree rebuilding: Some changes require widgets to be rebuilt. Try navigating between screens.
2. StatefulWidget issues: Changes to initState() won't apply until the widget is recreated.
3. Scope limitations: Hot Reload can't apply structural changes.

// This change requires Hot Restart, not Hot Reload
void main() {
  // Changed from runApp(MyApp()) to include provider
  runApp(
    ChangeNotifierProvider(
      create: (context) => AppState(),
      child: MyApp(),
    ),
  );
}

State Management Complications

When using state management solutions like GetX, Provider, or Bloc, you might encounter unexpected behavior after Hot Reload:

// Using GetX controller
class HomeController extends GetxController {
  final count = 0.obs;

  // Adding a new method requires Hot Restart
  void incrementTwice() {
    count.value += 2;
  }
}

For changes to controllers or state management logic, prefer Hot Restart to ensure consistency.

Best Practices for Efficient Development

1. Start with Hot Reload: Always try Hot Reload first for UI changes
2. Escalate as needed: If Hot Reload doesn't work, try Hot Restart
3. Full rebuild as last resort: Only stop and rebuild when absolutely necessary
4. Organize code for Hot Reload: Structure your code to maximize what can be changed with Hot Reload
5. Watch for state issues: Be aware that preserved state can sometimes mask or cause bugs

Conclusion

Understanding the differences between Hot Reload, Hot Restart, and full rebuilds is essential for efficient Flutter development. By knowing when to use each method, you can significantly speed up your development cycle while avoiding common pitfalls.

The next time you're making changes to your Flutter app, consider which refresh method is most appropriate. Your future self will thank you for the time saved and frustration avoided.

Have you encountered situations where one refresh method worked while others failed? Share your experiences in the comments below!