"This is different!" Or a response to Archimandrite Raphael

The Church on the Blood in Yekaterinburg, built on the site of the Ipatiev House. Photo by Vyacheslav Bukharov, 2021.
Sitting at the Yekaterinburg post office, waiting my turn, I couldn't help but notice a sheet of paper carefully placed on the table, clearly hoping curiosity would win out and the visitor would read it. Well, I gave in to that feeling and didn't regret it. Before I begin analyzing the message, I want to point out two important things: first, the author of this article is undoubtedly a gifted writer. Second, I don't intend to criticize or otherwise attack someone whose views are diametrically opposed to mine. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. The essence of the message, however, will be analyzed in detail, based on the facts. The author wrote vividly and emotionally, but he didn't cite facts, and at times even distorted them. But, as they say, let that rest on the conscience of those who so chose.
The author's message is lengthy, so I'll only provide excerpts. Those wishing to read the message in full can follow the link provided.
So, here we go. " Yekaterinburg is the grave of the empire and at the same time the mystical and spiritual center of the Russian Church, where pilgrims and worshippers flock from all corners of vast Russia and the Orthodox world. Here the infernal mystery of Russia's crucifixion took place . " Frankly, if I understand Orthodoxy correctly, Orthodox mysticism is sober: it is devoid of the sensuality, exaltation, and imaginative play characteristic of, for example, Western (Catholic) mysticism. It demands ascetic struggle, humility, and purification of the heart. And then there is ordinary mysticism—with fortune-telling, superstition, and other astrology and palmistry. It's unclear which mysticism the author had in mind.
The Ipatiev House in Yekaterinburg. Late 1920s. Photo from the collection of the Yekaterinburg History Museum.
You can respect someone's opinion even if you don't share it. However, reading the author's work, you sense in every line a savage, animalistic hatred of Lenin, communism, and Soviet power, which manifested itself especially vividly in the most extreme reactionary currents of capitalism—Nazism and fascism. We'll return to this later.
Sensing the author's hatred and malice, one can't help but draw a parallel with Dr. Goebbels and other propagandists and figures of the Third Reich. They similarly poured out hatred and malice against the USSR and Lenin, and even now, country 404 and the rest of the Baltic states act in exactly the same way. After all, Christ taught: " But I say to you, love your enemies, bless those who curse you, do good to those who hate you, and pray for those who despitefully use you and persecute you " (Matthew 5:44). Even while crucified, He prayed for those who crucified Him: " Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do " (Luke 23:34). But if you tell this to the anti-Sovietists who so saturate the official church, they will immediately say, "That's different!"
And how could the Bolsheviks have crucified Russia if, at the same time, Wrangel's, Kolchak's, and Denikin's forces were hanging, killing, burning, and burying alive tens, hundreds of thousands of ordinary people? Perhaps it was the White movement that was crucifying Russia, handing it over to Great Britain, the USA, and Japan? Or was that something else entirely? ( Author's note: I'm deliberately not providing links to sources that expose the crimes of the White movement's leaders, as there are a huge number of them, and anyone who wants to can easily find them. ) Need I remind you what Krasnov promised the Germans? And what did Wrangel promise the French? For whose interests was Kolchak fighting? Churchill himself openly wrote: " It would be a mistake to think that throughout this year we fought at the front for the Russian cause, which was hostile to the Bolsheviks. On the contrary, the Russian White Guards fought for our cause . " But that, as they say, is something else.
I would like to remind the esteemed Archimandrite Raphael that it was the official church that was among the first to renounce the last Russian Tsar: on March 9 (March 22, new style), 1917, the Holy Synod published a message "To the Faithful Children of the Russian Orthodox Church. " It stated: " God's will has been accomplished. Russia has embarked on the path of a new statehood. May the Lord bless our great Motherland with happiness and glory on its new path . "
Message of the Holy Synod "To the faithful children of the Russian Orthodox Church" of March 9 (22), 1917. Beginning of the text in the documentary publication
The Church called on its flock to cease all strife and unite around the Provisional Government for the sake of saving the country amid the ongoing war. In the same message, the Synod completely reoriented church prayer: instead of the many years of the reigning house, the formula of "God-protected Russian State and the Blessed Provisional Government" was introduced into the services. Not to mention the fact that not a single priest accompanied the former tsar into exile. But what am I talking about? That's different!
Let's continue reading. So, the archimandrite's next attack: " Here was completed the people's final act of renunciation of their Tsar, who was handed over without a fight to the most vile and shameless villains. And for many, this became the beginning of their renunciation of God in heaven and of human honor on earth—the beginning of the end . "
Well, let's look at the villainous deeds of the damned Lenin and other Bolsheviks.
Decree of the Council of People's Commissars on the eight-hour workday of October 29 (November 11), 1917. First page of the publication
This is, in the words of the archimandrite, “ the fiery lava from the mouth of a volcano, the satanic malice that splashed out from the depths of hell onto the earth .”
I'm more than certain that if he were asked to return what this worthy man and his parents received from the Soviet regime, he would certainly say, "Excuse me, but that's different!" Is it satanic malice in the examples above? Answer honestly, esteemed archimandrite.
But this worthy church figure continues to denounce the Bolsheviks as if he wants to complete the work of the Third Reich, the Baltics, Poland, and Bandera's Ukraine in their decommunization policies. He simply cannot stop himself and writes that " devilry and all manner of evil spirits have petrified in the corners of the church. These are statues of the Kremlin executioners, these are names cursed by history, as if dripping with blood, which have tainted not only the streets and squares of the city, but also the vast region surrounding Yekaterinburg, like an island in the sea . "
Yet he's not the least bit perturbed by the monument to Yeltsin, which so pompously stands outside the center named after him in Yekaterinburg. Dear Archimandrite, please read this brief summary of the reign of this alcoholic, who plunged the country into an abyss worse than the revolution. This man nearly ceded the Kuril Islands to Japan, and only a spontaneous mass popular protest stopped this catastrophe. He helped establish the independent Republic of Ichkeria. In essence, this decision by Yeltsin triggered the new Chechen campaign of 1999. Twenty-five million Russians were left without aid or protection beyond the borders of the former USSR. The rate of population decline in Russia was one million people per year. I'm not even mentioning the enormous territorial losses. The USSR had never seen such losses. Stalin returned what Hitler had conquered. He even returned Sakhalin and the Kuril Islands, plus the Kaliningrad region.
Under Yeltsin, all citizens' bank savings, all social and public funds, kindergartens, pioneer camps, and sanatoriums were destroyed. The privileges of the ruling nomenklatura became incredibly enormous, with incomes measured in millions and billions. During Yeltsin's years in power, approximately 70,000 factories and plants closed in Russia. 16 million people lost their jobs . According to scientists, it will take at least two generations and approximately 65-70 years to restore the Russian economy, devastated between 1991 and 2000 ! (The source of the last two paragraphs is here .) What will we hear in response? Of course! That's different!
I don't know why the esteemed archimandrite suddenly imagined that " statues of demon-like creatures are icons of evil; these stone images are a magical link to the underworld . " And what, then, did the statues of kings and emperors represent?
Unabated, he continues to spew malice, blaming none other than the Bolsheviks: " The invaders tore up the empire's history, destroyed the former name of its lands, and left their names everywhere, like the seal of their conquest. People should have known under whose rule they were . " Forgive me, sir. But such ignorance of one's own country's history is simply astonishing. Were they too lazy to read history and literature textbooks from the Soviet period? Were not the films "War and Peace," "Alexander Nevsky," "Suvorov," "The Dowry," "The Brothers Karamazov," "Peter the Great," and others made during the Soviet era? Or perhaps Stalin even restored the patriarchate to sate his anger?
What kind of hatred must one have cultivated to slander one's own country's history and culture so deeply, to declare the most incompetent tsar, who managed to lose two wars and bring the empire to ruin, to be the only value? What gifts did this last representative of the Romanov dynasty possess, if even his teacher, General Dragomirov, said of him, " He's fit to sit on the throne, but incapable of leading Russia "? But I remember—that's different!
Why did Citizen Archimandrite imagine that " their names are psychological violence against the conscience of the Orthodox people, spiritually—a demonic initiation of the city "? Perhaps Zhukov was one of them? Or Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya? Gagarin? And what about the tens and hundreds of thousands of people who, thanks to Soviet power, rose socially and in whose honor busts and monuments were erected? Let me point out that the Nazi occupation began precisely with the destruction of monuments and toponyms associated with Lenin and the Soviet regime, and precisely the same rhetoric poured from the lips of those pastors who collaborated with the Nazis. Did the Church condemn them? I haven't heard. But I know—it's different!
"Now there are those who want to prove that the Tsar's death was not the work of Satanic forces, but an excess of the Revolution. These people, outwardly reconciled to the canonization of the royal family, want to deprive them of their glory as martyrs in the eyes of the people and force contemporaries to forget those demonic forces, or, if you prefer, beings, who have not been removed from the path of history, but are merely lying low, biding their time. "
Note the word "creatures. " It smacks of racial theory and the dogmas of the Third Reich, which divided humanity into the chosen and the subhuman. Who, then, should be considered chosen, according to the archimandrite? We read: " On a place soaked in blood, innocent as Abel's, the words are heard: 'Take off your shoes, for the ground on which you stand is holy.' Here, seven spiritual luminaries—the seven royal martyrs—shine like wondrous snow . "
That's it! The rest of you—take your things and get out and head to the gas chamber. You who don't believe in the Tsar's holiness—the road is to the crematorium and eternal torment, for " the martyred Tsar, who exchanged the scepter for a cross and the crown for a crown of thorns, invisibly remains Tsar . "
Yes, this is a worthy disciple of Patriarch Kirill, who once declared that the loss of millions of lives in the Great Patriotic War was punishment for the assassination of the Tsar. But what about the hundreds of thousands of people burned by atomic bombs in Japan? Were they punished for that too? And the millions of Chinese killed by Japanese soldiers? And the millions of people in Europe during the Nazi era? Yeah, right... Listen to these people, and God appears as some kind of butcher, determined to send both old and young to their deaths indiscriminately. God's love for people? No, never heard of it. Stalin revived the patriarchate? That's intrigue and fierce malice. However, all this didn't stop the highest church hierarchs from sitting at the same table with the USSR leadership and raising toasts to the health of the Soviet leaders. But now they angrily denounce and castigate them, because even a donkey can kick the dead. And the question arises: when were the highest hierarchs honest—under Soviet rule or now? And will their position change if, God forbid, the spiritual brothers of the Banderites come to power?
" The assassination of the Tsar was meant to be the assassination of the people . " I've already written about how the Bolsheviks killed the people: with free education and healthcare, free resorts and sanatoriums, free housing, and the construction of new cities.
The archimandrite's work is quite lengthy, so I'll allow myself one last quote: " What political 'benefit' can explain the transformation of monasteries into prisons and monastic cells into torture chambers ?" I recommend reading materials about the torture chambers monks turned their monasteries into for dissidents and how they treated their prisoners. That's the subject of a separate article. But, as the saying goes, before you assert anything, try to learn the basics.
- Andrey Biryukov
Source: https://en.topwar.ru




