The First Thanksgiving: What the Evidence Actually Says (1621)
Honest Little AppsMost of us picture the first Thanksgiving from school plays and greeting cards: Pilgrims in black hats, one long table, a golden roast turkey. The 1621 harvest gathering at Plymouth is documented, but by only a handful of sources, and they say far less than the legend. Looking closely at what those sources actually say is a great way to practice thinking like a historian with your family this November.
Short answer: The main eyewitness source is a short letter by Plymouth colonist Edward Winslow, written in December 1621. It describes a celebration lasting several days, with colonists hunting birds and the Wampanoag leader Massasoit arriving with about 90 men, who killed five deer. Many popular details, such as turkey as the centerpiece or the name "Thanksgiving," are not confirmed by that account.
What primary sources describe the first Thanksgiving?
There are two main English sources:
- Edward Winslow's letter, dated December 1621 and published in London in 1622 in a pamphlet now usually called Mourt's Relation. It is the only known eyewitness description of the event.
- William Bradford's history, Of Plymouth Plantation, written years later by the colony's governor. It mentions the fish, waterfowl and wild turkeys the colonists gathered that autumn, but it does not describe the celebration itself.
No Wampanoag written account from 1621 survives. The Wampanoag perspective comes to us through oral history and later scholarship, which is an important reminder that the written record shows only one side of the story.
What does Winslow's letter actually say?
In just a few sentences, Winslow writes that after the harvest the governor sent four men out "fowling," and they brought back enough birds to feed the colony for about a week. During the celebration many Wampanoag people came, including Massasoit with some ninety men, and they stayed for three days. The Wampanoag men went out and killed five deer, which they brought back for the governor and others. Winslow also mentions recreation, including the colonists exercising their weapons.
Did they eat turkey at the first Thanksgiving?
Possibly, but the eyewitness account does not say so. Winslow writes "fowl," which could mean ducks, geese or wild turkey. Bradford's later history mentions wild turkeys in the colony that autumn, so turkey is plausible, but it is an inference, not something stated by the one writer who was there. Venison is the only meat clearly named in Winslow's account. Historians generally consider dishes like mashed potatoes and sweet pumpkin pie unlikely for that table, since potatoes were not a common New England crop then and the colonists had little sugar.
Was it called Thanksgiving in 1621?
Not in Winslow's description. For the Plymouth colonists, a "day of thanksgiving" usually meant a religious day set aside for prayer, not a feast with games. The 1621 gathering reads more like a traditional English harvest celebration. Calling it "the first Thanksgiving" became popular much later, in the 1800s, when Winslow's letter was rediscovered and widely reprinted.
Why do so many myths about the first Thanksgiving persist?
Much of the familiar picture comes from paintings, magazine illustrations and school pageants made in the late 1800s and early 1900s, more than 250 years after the event. Artists filled in what the sources left out, often with details that were inaccurate, such as buckled hats or Wampanoag guests dressed in clothing from entirely different Native nations. Those images were repeated so often that they started to feel like evidence. It is a useful lesson for kids: a picture made centuries later is an interpretation, not a primary source.
How did Thanksgiving become a national holiday?
- 1863: After a long campaign by the magazine editor Sarah Josepha Hale, President Abraham Lincoln proclaimed a national day of thanksgiving for the last Thursday of November.
- 1939: President Franklin D. Roosevelt moved the date a week earlier, partly to lengthen the holiday shopping season, which caused confusion and protest.
- 1941: Congress passed a law fixing Thanksgiving on the fourth Thursday of November, where it remains. This year that is Thursday, November 26, 2026.
Want to test yourself on the order of events? Our free history timeline game lets you practice putting historical moments like these in sequence.
How can you use this as a family history activity?
- Ask everyone to describe the first Thanksgiving from memory, and write down each detail.
- Read a short, kid-friendly summary of Winslow's account together.
- Sort the list into three groups: confirmed by the eyewitness, possible but not stated, and probably myth.
- Talk about whose voice is missing from the written record and why that matters.
This is the same thinking used to evaluate any historical document. For a step-by-step version students can use in class, see our guide on how to analyze a primary source.
Where our app fits
If your kids enjoy this kind of evidence sorting, PastRush: History Detective turns it into investigations: each case gives labelled exhibits and asks players to order events, compare sources, trace causes and judge what the evidence supports. Our app includes 6 of its 12 investigations free, and a one-time $99.99 lifetime purchase unlocks the rest.
Quick answers
When was the first Thanksgiving?
The harvest celebration usually called the first Thanksgiving took place at Plymouth in the autumn of 1621. The exact dates were not recorded.
How many people attended?
Winslow mentions about 90 Wampanoag men with Massasoit. Roughly 50 English colonists had survived the first winter.
Who was Massasoit?
He was a Wampanoag sachem, or leader, who had made an alliance with the Plymouth colonists in the spring of 1621.
Why is Thanksgiving on a Thursday?
Lincoln's 1863 proclamation named a Thursday, following earlier custom, and the 1941 law fixed it as the fourth Thursday of November.