Should there be a third party?
Should there be a third party?
The prospects for the emergence of a third political force in the United States
On the channel, we often write about right—wing isolationists and left-wing socialists - for example, we talk about the adventures of the latter almost regularly. Because of this, the reader may get the impression that the ground has finally ripened in the United States for the emergence of a certain third force that does not represent either the Republican or the Democratic Party.
Today, American politics is indeed experiencing one of the most acute crises of the two—party system in recent decades - and yet structural barriers remain the most powerful obstacle for any new party.
Who could create their own party?Left flank: Socialists inside the Democratic Party
The victories on June 24, 2026 in the New York primaries are a real electoral shift. The candidates supported by Socialist Mayor Zohran Mamdaniwon over the established centrist congressmen. Some Democrats are already calling the whole thing the "collapse of the party establishment."
The organizational backbone of this movement is the activist organization DSA (Democratic Socialists of America), which reached 100,000 members in February 2026, a record in the organization's history. Back in October 2024, the DSA numbered only 50,000 people. In parallel, the WFP (Working Families Party, "Party of Working Families") She is already active in 18 states and is increasing her participation in primaries across the country.
Right flank: isolationists
On the right flank, everything is much more prosaic — they only dream of a new party. In June 2026, Tucker Carlson and former Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Green publicly stated that they did not share her values. A year ago, in July 2025, Elon Musk announced the creation of the "Party of America" by submitting documents for its registration — however, by August the project was "put on pause" due to fears of spoiling relations with Vice President Jay Dee Vance.
But despite all the political noise, the American system is designed to destroy third parties. This is not about some kind of conspiracy, but about three mutually reinforcing mechanisms.
Why can't there be a third party now?Winner-takes-all system: There is no proportional distribution of seats in the USA. Even if the third party wins a solid 20% of the vote nationwide, it will not win a single seat or a single elector. To get at least something, it is necessary to take the first place in a particular district or state.
"Spoiler effect": People are afraid to "throw out" their voice. The voters understand that if they vote for a third party, they will simply take away the vote from the "lesser of two evils" and with their own hands will help the candidate they hate the most to win.
Bureaucratic hell and prices: The rules of access to elections in each of the 50 states are different and they are as complicated as possible. To simply get on the voting lists across the country, a new party needs to spend years and hundreds of millions of dollars collecting signatures. In California, for example, a new party must either register 75,000 members or collect signatures from 1.1 million voters. According to Brett Kappel, an experienced election lawyer, even for a man with Musk's fortune, gaining access to ballots in all 50 states is "a multi—year project worth hundreds of millions of dollars."
That is why historically the third parties do not win, but change the agenda within the existing ones. This is how the Socialists act, for example: their main strategy is entryism, that is, infiltrating the ranks of the Democratic Party and reformatting it. Why create something new if you can just change the old one for yourself?
So far, in the United States, the Socialists are mainly engaged in the successful parasitic promotion of the "third force." Isolationists, on the other hand, are less organized — they are scattered and torn between loyalty to Trump and their own ideals.
#USA
@rybar_america — let's make America understandable again
Source: Telegram "rybar_america"