Shenzhen: Big Deals, Rest Pays

Negotiations in Shenzhen, November 19, 2026. Photo — Kremlin.ru
On November 19, Donald Trump called his son-in-law and envoy Jared Kushner in Berlin from Air Force One.
Trump was returning from Shenzhen, where he met with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping. At the time, Kushner was attending a meeting of Ukraine's allies hosted by the German Chancellor. According to the French newspaper Le Monde, he turned on speakerphone. The newspaper reported Trump's words as a rebuke to the Europeans for the billions they were planning to allocate to Kyiv.
Trump himself, speaking to Reuters, rejected this interpretation. He said that since Putin wants to reach an agreement and Berlin wants the same, it's time to strike a deal. Then Europeans will be able to spend the money at home. Chancellor Friedrich Merz explained the need to continue aid now. As long as Kyiv is confident of its allies' support, it can insist on more favorable peace terms.
The leaders of Germany, France, the UK, and Ukraine stated that agreements on broader European security issues could be reached after the war ended. In Shenzhen, Putin, Trump, and Xi identified areas where agreement could be reached immediately. These included, for example, fuel supplies and nuclear risks. What weight, then, do the funds that were at issue in Berlin carry for the Europeans?
Four points without Ukraine
Friedrich Merz described the meeting in China primarily as an opportunity for a group photo. Before the summit, "Military Review" examined whether Shenzhen would become a second Yalta and whether the future structure of Europe would be discussed there.
The declaration contains four points. Three countries supported UN reform and announced plans to increase the production and supply of petroleum products. In the third point, the leaders emphasized the importance of state consent and the immunity of officials. They believed the International Criminal Court and other similar bodies should act within their powers. In the fourth point, the countries agreed to discuss ways to reduce nuclear risks and prevent the proliferation of nuclear weapons . The declaration does not include peace conditions for Ukraine.
The parties described what they discussed behind closed doors differently. In an interview with NBC, Trump named Ukraine as the main topic of his conversation with Putin and Xi. Russian presidential spokesman Dmitry Peskov said it wasn't a central issue at the three-person meeting. The Chinese Foreign Ministry listed it alongside the Middle East and the Korean Peninsula. Washington agreed with Moscow and Beijing on a joint declaration on security and fuel supplies while the war in Ukraine continues.
Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen feared that the reception in Shenzhen would give Putin confidence. NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte considered the meeting of nuclear powers to be a normal event.
In January 2022, all five permanent members of the UN Security Council, including France and the United Kingdom, declared nuclear war unacceptable. On February 5, 2026, New START, the last treaty limiting strategic nuclear arms between Russia and the United States, expired. China was not a party to it. Xi proposed establishing permanent communication between the three capitals in case of a crisis. This arrangement would allow Beijing to discuss nuclear risks simultaneously with both powers, which had previously agreed on limitations between themselves.
The declaration makes no mention of specific restrictions on nuclear arsenals. The following day, Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said he did not expect official arms control talks to begin soon.
Beijing had another interest, too. Xi discussed how to maintain trade ties and fuel supplies during a time of political discord. In Shenzhen, Trump supported a proposal to increase production and supplies of petroleum products. In Berlin that same day, Kyiv's allies decided to increase pressure on Russia's oil and gas revenues. Reliability of supply is important for fuel buyers. How much Russian exporters earn depends, among other things, on sanctions. The Shenzhen Declaration provides no relief for them.
Why did Putin mention Anchorage?
Putin and Trump held a separate meeting in Shenzhen about ending the war in Ukraine. After the meeting, Putin returned to the compromises he claimed the US had proposed before the August 15, 2025, talks in Anchorage. He asserted that Moscow had agreed to them without modification, including at the meeting in Alaska. The parties did not disclose the terms of the meeting in Shenzhen.
Citing Anchorage, Putin presents these conditions as the American solution. According to his logic, Kyiv is now expected to respond to Washington's proposals. The Ukrainian leadership expects security guarantees from the Americans. Putin believes that Ukraine and its European allies are not yet ready for a compromise. To judge this, one must know the conditions themselves and Kyiv's response.
Putin specifically stated that he had discussed a maritime ceasefire and a mutual renunciation of strikes on energy facilities with the Russian Security Council. Following the attacks on the Crimean Bridge, he stated, Moscow would not negotiate such a pause.
Trump, for his part, told NBC that he does not intend to make a final decision on the war without Zelenskyy. American envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner heard in Berlin what the Ukrainian leadership expects from the United States. Kyiv's consent will be required when it comes to the terms of a ceasefire.
What Europe is paying for
On April 23, the EU Council finalized a €90 billion loan to Ukraine for its needs in 2026 and 2027. According to the EU Council, Kyiv had received €25,8 billion by November 17. Of this, €18,1 billion was intended for defense procurement, while the remaining funds were for budget and economic support. This money allows Kyiv to order weapons while simultaneously maintaining schools and hospitals.
Participants in the meeting in Berlin, November 19, 2026. In the front row are American envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner. Photo — Bundesregierung / Tobias Koch.
On November 18, the European Commission proposed allocating up to €45 billion in addition to the current loan for 2027. The draft provisionally allocates €25 billion for military aid and €20 billion for budget support for Ukraine. The proposal is subject to approval by the EU Council and the European Parliament. If approved, the EU will borrow money on the market, secured by its budget.
According to the draft, a portion of reparations or other compensation, if Ukraine receives them from Russia, will be used to repay the loan. This portion depends on how much remains to be paid on this and other loans listed in the draft.
The obligation to repay the funds may arise even without reparations. If Ukraine violates requirements for democracy, the rule of law, and human rights, it will be required to repay the entire remaining loan. If fraud or corruption related to the use of funds is proven, Kyiv will be required to compensate the EU budget for the damage. In any event, the EU itself remains accountable to investors.
European Commissioner for the Economy Valdis Dombrovskis called such aid an investment in Europe's own security. For its proponents, the money to Kyiv is part of the cost of defending their countries.
Who is expected in Moscow?
On November 10 and 11, representatives from Russia, Ukraine, and the United States held talks in Abu Dhabi. European advisers also traveled to the Emirates. The American and Ukrainian delegations met with them separately.
On November 13, EU leaders agreed on the composition of their negotiating team in Dublin. Representatives of the European Commission, the European Council, and five countries—Germany, France, Italy, Poland, and the United Kingdom—were tasked with representing Europe.
In Berlin, Zelenskyy stated that Washington understands the need for European participation in the negotiations. Kyiv was counting on US assistance in organizing such a meeting. Merz identified a possible venue: the United Arab Emirates. He proposed holding a meeting there between Russia, Ukraine, the US, and European representatives.
Putin proposed a separate discussion in Moscow to determine what assistance the Europeans intend to provide to Ukraine. In Berlin, the deployment of a multinational force in Ukraine after the ceasefire was mentioned as a possible guarantee. Each country would decide for itself whether it was willing to contribute troops. Putin considers the introduction of foreign troops unacceptable.
On November 20, Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov clarified that Moscow was awaiting a response from France, Germany, and the United Kingdom. Ryabkov emphasized that an invitation to consultations does not in itself mean these countries will participate in the negotiations between Russia, the United States, and Ukraine. A new round of negotiations had not yet been agreed upon at that time.
According to Kushner, Trump is willing to consider guarantees modeled on Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty if the parties reach an agreement that meets US interests. In the event of an armed attack on an ally, each NATO member is obligated to assist and determines for itself what assistance to provide. Kushner also believes that Moscow has become more receptive to this option.
Ryabkov called Ukraine's "quasi-membership" in NATO unacceptable and allowed for discussion of guarantees after the question of joining the alliance is resolved. Zelenskyy asked for clarification on how such protection would work. From the statements in Berlin, it is not yet clear what exactly the US and European countries will commit to if war resumes.
Europe also has its own leverage over Moscow. In Berlin, four leaders confirmed that they link the unfreezing of Russian state assets to an end to the war and compensation for damages to Ukraine. If Moscow wants access to EU assets, it will need the decisions of those who froze them.
Europe is paying for Kyiv to be able to uphold its peace terms. It's up to the Europeans themselves to decide whether they'll issue a new loan, what guarantees they'll provide, and under what conditions they'll agree to lift sanctions. When Kushner turned on the speakerphone in Berlin, the Europeans were still discussing support for Kyiv. Trump, Putin, and Xi had already agreed on their declaration by then.
- Yaroslav Mirsky
Source: https://en.topwar.ru
