Реферат: South Dakota Vs Dole Essay Research Paper
👉🏻👉🏻👉🏻 ВСЯ ИНФОРМАЦИЯ ДОСТУПНА ЗДЕСЬ ЖМИТЕ 👈🏻👈🏻👈🏻
South Dakota Vs Dole Essay, Research Paper
In 1987, the power of the 21st Amendment of the Constitution was in question by South Dakota and the State Secretary of Transportation (1983-87),1 Elizabeth Dole. The 21st Amendment declares that states have complete control over production, sale, and transportation of alcohol and that liquor importation and sale are no longer prohibited among states of the US (since the prohibition law of the 18th Amendment). However, a federal law states that in order for a portion of federal highway funds to be given by the federal government to an individual state, that state must adopt a minimum drinking age of 21 years of age. Michigan is an example of this law, for because our minimum drinking age is 21, we receive highway funds from the federal government.
Therefore, this law directs Dole to withhold a percentage of highway funds from states who refuse to set their drinking age law at 21 or over. South Dakota was one such state, with a minimum age of 19 required to buy beer up to 3.2% alcohol content. They claimed that the federal law violated constitutional limitations on Congress spending power (Article I) and also violated the 21st Amendment. South Dakota believed that the power of setting a drinking age is and should be reserved to the state, and their power was weakened by this federal law.
The main issue confronted in this case was whether or not the 21st Amendment was violated by this federal law on state drinking age. The case was heard by a US District Court (dismissed case, South Dakota appealed), then the Court of Appeals affirmed the case and it was then heard by the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court decision was a 7:2 vote that the federal government’s law did not violate the 21st Amendment in any way, and that the law was a valid use of congressional spending power.
The Supreme Court agreed that the Congress did not have the power to impose a national drinking age by direct legislation. Congress did, however, have the power to set conditions on receipt of federal funds, therefore mostly controlling those funds. It was said that “Congress encourages uniformity in drinking ages.”2 This means that Congress is regulating the drinking age indirectly but does not violate any constitutional Amendment. “Congress can tempt, not coerce.”2 There is a difference between tempting and coercing, and between forcing compliance and buying compliance, the Congress executing the latter action. They stressed only mild encouragement to US states to change the drinking age.
Another factor affecting the Supreme Court’s decision on the case was the fact that only a mere 5% of federal highway funds was at stake, so a decision either way would not change money matters severely. Also, the decision satisfies the requirement for congressional spending for the “general welfare” of the states, not for personal advancement but for the improvement of the US as a whole.
One point that the federal government was trying to stress with their highway fund/ drinking age law was that the lack of uniformity among US state drinking age laws was an interstate problem, and a dangerous one as well. The Congress wished to find uniformity within a drinking age law, or regulate the sale and commerce of liquor in another way. However they could only do this by indirect means.
The case of South Dakota vs. Dole ended with the decision that the federal law backed by Dole was not a violation of the 21st Amendment used by South Dakota. Therefore, in order to receive federal highway funds, South Dakota must comply with the federal law and raise their minimum drinking age to 21 years of age.
“Dole, Elizabeth.” Compton’s Interactive Encyclopedia. Copyright 1996. Softkey Multimedia Inc. (computer)
United States Government: Democracy in Action. Glencoe, pp. 103-4.
Название: South Dakota Vs Dole Essay Research Paper
Раздел: Топики по английскому языку
Тип: реферат
Добавлен 00:13:24 28 октября 2010 Похожие работы
Просмотров: 6
Комментариев: 12
Оценило: 2 человек
Средний балл: 5
Оценка: неизвестно Скачать
Срочная помощь учащимся в написании различных работ. Бесплатные корректировки! Круглосуточная поддержка! Узнай стоимость твоей работы на сайте 64362.ru
Привет студентам) если возникают трудности с любой работой (от реферата и контрольных до диплома), можете обратиться на FAST-REFERAT.RU , я там обычно заказываю, все качественно и в срок) в любом случае попробуйте, за спрос денег не берут)
Да, но только в случае крайней необходимости.
Реферат: South Dakota Vs Dole Essay Research Paper
Реферат На Тему Ранние И Национальные Религии
Практическое задание по теме Цифро-аналоговое преобразование сигналов в микроконтроллерных системах
Курсовая работа по теме Особенности работы социального педагога в ДОУ
Дипломная Работа На Тему Исследование Образа Современного Педагога
Воображение Сочинение 9.3 По Тексту Толстого
Герой 21 Века Какой Он Итоговое Сочинение
Эссе На Тему Древней Греции
Реферат: Рекламне дослідження ринку
Курсовая работа по теме Анализ экономико-статистического развития отрасли растениеводства
Курсовая работа: Совет Федерации Федерального Собрания Российской Федерации
Реферат по теме Основные этапы развития физики
Курсовая работа по теме Анализ ценовой политики ООО 'Мегаполис'
Реферат: A Progressive Democracy Essay Research Paper The
Реферат: Коллективное поведение. Скачать бесплатно и без регистрации
Исследование Преломления Света Лабораторная Работа
Курсовая работа по теме Учет и обработка данных об учебной литературе кафедры
Курсовая работа по теме Пути повышения эффективности рекламной кампании
Контрольная работа: Виды отчетов консультанта
Реферат: Мезозойская эра. Скачать бесплатно и без регистрации
Эссе На Тему Спорт И Отдых
Реферат: Теория измерений
Курсовая работа: Оцінка фінансового стану та діагностика ймовірності настання банкрутства ВАТ НАСК Оранта
Реферат: Сущность и задачи кассационного производства в уголовном процессе