Real Estate vs Stock Market- Which Is a Better Investment?

Real Estate vs Stock Market- Which Is a Better Investment?

SUBODH SHARMA

Should you invest in real estate or stock market – or both?

It primarily depends on your personal choice, knowledge and your financial goal.

If you are an Indian, it’s likely that you’d prefer real estate over stocks. It’s in our DNA. As real estate is tangible, it provides stronger emotional fulfilment and joy over investing in stocks. Investing in the stock market gives higher returns but also has higher risk than real estate.

There is no single asset that provides high returns with low risk. Asset allocation with right mix of assets (stock, debt, real estate, gold ,etc.) can get you high risk-adjusted returns.

Investing is not about chasing returns but creating wealth.

Key Elements Of Real Estate Over Stocks

My preference for real estate has following reasons.

As current lifestyle is dynamic, I prefer renting a flat in a good society to buying a house and paying high EMI.

My views on real estate :

1. Wealth

  • Financial Wealth – Investment in real estate – a property or a piece of land is a great way to create financial wealth.
  • Status Wealth – If you are after status in the society, this is one way to create it. Ownership of properties is considered a symbol of high status in many cultures.
  • Physical and Social Wealth -In the COVID-19 situation, this is a good time to invest a plot and enjoy WFF(Work From Farm). Farming is not only highly fulfilling but great for your physical well-being. You may also connect with your neighbor-landowners and expand your social circle.

2. Retirement

  • Real estate is a great source of passive income during retirement. Those who can afford to buy multiple rental properties can have a steady source of passive income upon retiring.
  • Ownership of a piece of land has the potential to pay you handsomely if you decide to sell it during retirement.
  • Land investments are becoming more popular due to reasons such WFH and health. Building a farm could be a dream come true for many during retirement.
  • Inflation Protected – Inflation is the biggest enemy during retirement. Your property and your rental income are both protected from inflation. With rental properties, your rent appreciates as per inflation. Most retirees have their money parked in bank accounts and earn low-interest rates which slowly depletes against inflation.
  • Money is Protected – Your retirement money in assets like stocks, bonds, bank accounts is easily accessible. When you have easy access to money many times it becomes difficult to control your emotions especially when your family or friends need our financial assistance. Children often demand money from their retired parents to support their lifestyles. For retirees, their retirement income is their lifeline and must be protected.
  • Also, with increasing bank scams, online frauds, real estate is one of the safest ways to protect your money in the long run. Your money in real estate is locked, safe, appreciates over time and supports your living.

3. Generational Wealth

  • Real estate generates wealth for future generation as you may never need to sell your property. You can pass it on to your children.

4. Emotional Investment

  • Owning a property gives you a huge emotional and sentimental investment. You have an intrinsic level of fulfilment and happiness.

5. LAP(Loan Against Property)

  • You can avail loan against property (LAP) which is a secured loan that banks, housing finance companies, and NBFCs provide against residential property. It is cheaper than a personal loan and you can continue to live in the property even after the loan is availed.

6. Low Risk

  • Real Estate is less volatile as compared to Stocks. The stock market can have a drastic fall and rise which is not the case with real estate. Losing 20% in a day in the stock market requires a strong gut to still stay invested and wait for the market to rebound. This doesn’t happen in real estate. This is one of the safest investment options globally.

7. Land

“Buy land, they’re not making it anymore.” – Mark Twain

  • Land always appreciates over the long term.
  • Property values can increase at exponential rates, and real estate investment can help you become rich in the long run. You might have heard of many ordinary people who sold their lands due to urbanization and got rich overnight.
  • Although buying a piece of land is not so easy and is also not very transparent, digitalization of land records have made it a little easier. Nowadays plots are also available within gated communities which is a safer investment.

Own your piece of earth and the sky above it.

8. Passive Income

  • Rental properties are a great way to make passive income. Your rental yield grows as per inflation and thus provides you passive income not just for you but for generations to come.

9. Long Term Commitment

  • Long-term commitment is very difficult in the stock market as you need a strong gut to stay put in the market through its ups and downs. As liquidity is low in real estate, people in a way are forced to commit to it for a longer period of time. You may also not sell it ever due to emotional attachment. Long-term commitment triggers the power of compounding that generates wealth for you.

10. Reforms/Growth in the Real Estate

  • Model Tenancy Act introduced by the Central government of India will further formalie and bolster rental housing in India.
  • At present, home loan interest rates in India are at a 15-year low at 7 %, and stamp duty cuts are also there in states like Maharashtra.
  • RERA(Regulation and Development Act) has also boosted investors’ confidence in the realty sector. The interests of home buyers are well protected.
  • According to an estimate by the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA), India’s real estate sector is valued at USD 200-billion market in 2021 and will hit USD 1 trillion by 2030.
  • The real estate sector is the second largest employer after agriculture in India and contributes 7-8 percent to the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) growth of India.
  • Real estate is a preferred asset for NRIs to invest in India and this is growing year on year. This also accelerates growth in this sector.
  • Real estate becomes an attractive investment due to the COVID-19 climate. There is strong demand from both domestic and NRI investors, and FDI investments after COVID-19. There is an increased demand from international investors who are eager to relocate their investment from China to India. Higher demand will boost this sector in the years to come.
  • Smart cities can be a good option for property investors and potential for price appreciation is high.
  • The housing and real estate sector is heading into the best of times. In over 50 years of my work life, I have not seen housing affordability better than where it is today in the country. I have not seen such easy liquidity conditions and interest rates at such record low levels – Deepak Parekh , Chairman of Housing Development Finance Corporation(HDFC)

11. Power Of Leverage

  • Real estate’s strongest advantage is leverage. You buy with the mortgage support from the bank and your tenant pays your EMI. For example, you make a 20% down payment on a Rs 50,00,000 house. Two years go by and the house increases in value to Rs 55,00,000, or 10%. The return on your down payment – your ownership in the deal – is a stunning 50% minus additional expenses like govt charges and other fees.
  • No other asset provides you the option to leverage. You have an options market in the stock market, but you risk losing your entire investment.
  • Leverage is good debt and amplifies your returns in the long run.

12. Tax Benefits

  • For salaried people, you can get an IT rebate by investing in real estate in India under Section 24, sections 80C, 80EE, etc.
  • Depreciation – Depreciation is the most powerful tax benefit of investing in real estate and improving your cash flow towards house loan repayment. You can claim tax deductions for the renovation expenditures and the depreciated purchase price.

13. Complete Control

  • In real estate, you are in full control of the property business. You can customize it to generate high returns like converting 2 BHK into 3 BHK, co-working, furnished/unfurnished conditions, collaborating with AirB&B, etc.
  • In the Stock market, promoters of the company and fund managers have more control of your investments.

14. Real Asset

  • How do you like reading a book – online or a paper book? You feel more connected with the it when you read a physical book. This feeling is absent online.
  • Ownership of physical assets brings strong financial security, and also a sense of status in society (if you are after one).
  • In our society, it’s a taboo to tell how much money you have in the stock market or any other assets but surprisingly it’s quite welcome when you tell how many properties you own.
  • Indian households mostly save and invest through physical assets, and this will be the trend due to uncertainties in the financial assets.

To summarize, real estate is an “IDEAL” investment; Income, Demand, Equity, Appreciation, Leverage.

Key Elements Of Stocks Over Real Estate

India is on a multi-year bull run and as economy grows it reflects in the stock market too. Stocks market is a wealth building machine however highly volatile also. To create wealth in the stock market , I practice , Evidence Based Investing (EBI) to keep my emotions away .

My views on stock market:

1. Costs

  • The cost of investing in the stock market is much less and you can buy a mutual fund as low as Rs 100. Buying real estate requires a significant amount and also incurs many additional expenses like stamp duty, registration charges, ongoing maintenance costs, property taxes.

2. Wealth

  • Financial Wealth – With stocks, you are buying ownership. In the long run, you can be rich by owning a great company or even by investing in mutual funds. The richest people in the world have ownership of the companies and they also hold their wealth in real estate. Diverting excess profits from the stock market into real estate.

3. Returns

  • Historical returns of the stock market are much higher than real estate. Actually, the stock market is great for generating returns and real estate for capital protection and growth . So you can rebalance excess profits from the stock market and deploy them into real estate to protect the capital.

4. Transparency

  • A share of TCS is the same as every other share. The price is updated constantly, and it is accessible to anyone. On the other hand, there is no benchmark for real estate prices and it varies as per the location. Also buying and selling in the stock market is very transparent as compared to real estate.

5. Ease of Investing

  • Buying and selling in the stock market are very easy whereas real estate investing is very cumbersome and not transparent enough.
  • In Stocks, you can do everything online and in small amounts as SIP. Buying real estate requires a mental and physical effort due to the lengthy process and requires a big investment amount.

6. Diversification

  • The stock market provides great diversification across assets. You can choose mutual funds, direct stocks, invest in many companies. Within the mutual fund’s ecosystem, you have many options to diversify.
  • In real estate, there are not many options available in India. REIT (Real Estate Investment Trust) is still not popular in India. You have an option of investing in rental, commercial, or land.

Right Mix: Stock Market Weds Real Estate

I think stocks and real estate compliment each other. Together they provide the best risk-adjusted returns. Stock market and real estate have a low correlation. During the bull run when the market outperforms you can book some profit and divert them towards real estate. This is rebalancing (Sell-High, Buy-Low) to reduce risk in the portfolio. With profit booked from the stock market, invest into the rental properties and repeat.

Invest in a rental property that has a potential of high rental yield and consider price appreciation as a bonus, so location matters a lot. Pay 20% of down payment and 80% financed through home loan. As rental yield is low in India around 3% and interest rate at 7%, so it requires 4-5 years of EMI obligation, and then as rent is increasing and EMI remains steady, you tenant take care of your EMI, and again it’s time to rebalance from the stock market and reinvest into real estate and this cycle continues.

In 10-20 years of your working life, you can own multiple rental properties to support your lifestyle with lifetime passive income.

Think Stock Market Think Passive Investing! Think Real Estate Think Passive Income.

From my monthly investment basket, I do passive investing with 50% into the stock market as SIP and 50% as good EMI(Leverage) for passive income.

Investing mindset of the majority of Indians are ;

  • Low risk
  • Tangible asset for financial stability and security
  • Ownership of properties for status wealth
  • Satisfactory return as compared to high return

Overall , in my opinion real estate scores higher as compared to stock for an Indian mindset. As per the RBI report, ~80% of investments in India are locked in Real Estate. The investment in Financial Assets (eg. Stocks) is ~5%




Report Page