Malibu Surfer Files Federal Injunction Claiming Ownership of Wave He "Definitely Called"
Violet WoolfNinth Circuit asked to rule on whether a six-foot right-hander constitutes private property after verbal declaration and aggressive eye contact
Malibu Surfer Files Federal Injunction Claiming Ownership of Wave He "Definitely Called"
MALIBU, CA -- A 34-year-old surfer identified only as "Chadwick J." filed suit in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals on Tuesday seeking exclusive ownership rights to a wave that broke off Point Dume at approximately 11:42 a.m., claiming he had established undeniable territorial dominance through the time-honored legal mechanism of yelling "Mine!" from the lineup.
The lawsuit, described by his attorney as "the most important property rights case since Malibu Colony vs. That One German Family Who Parked in Front of the Beach," argues that the wave in question -- a clean, six-foot right-hander that peeled for approximately nine seconds before expiring in a wash of white water -- constituted a "discoverable natural asset" that Chadwick had "pre-identified, spiritually claimed, and begun paddling toward" a full three seconds before it was ridden by a tourist on a rental foam board.
Legal Experts Baffled, Also a Little Jealous
"We have no framework for this," said Professor Gerald Hatch of the Pepperdine School of Law, who has taught property rights for twenty-two years and had never considered the ocean. "Traditionally, waves are considered res nullius, belonging to no one. However, Chadwick presents a compelling argument that his verbal declaration and directional head nod constituted sufficient notice under California common law."
The defendant, a tourist from Naperville, Illinois named Dale Pruitt, says he never heard the claim, adding that he was "just trying not to die" and that he thought the foam board rental shop had said the surfing was "easy." Pruitt suffered minor abrasions and a profound sense of having disappointed someone, which, as any surfer will tell you, is the correct psychological state for a beginner.
Chadwick is asking for $2.4 million in damages, which he calculated by multiplying the approximate value of the wave -- "a solid six, maybe a six-five with that little shoulder section" -- by the number of seconds of ride time lost, times his subjective assessment of how good he looked paddling for it. He has retained the same attorney who previously represented a Venice Beach drummer seeking royalties from anyone who has ever heard a bongo and felt vaguely annoyed.
A Pattern of Aquatic Entitlement
The case has attracted attention from surfing commentators across Southern California, several of whom note that Chadwick has a well-documented history of aggressive wave-claiming behavior, including a 2022 incident in which he attempted to mark his paddle-out route with traffic cones and a 2023 confrontation at Zuma Beach in which he produced a laminated "Priority Card" he had made himself at a Kinko's in Woodland Hills.
Legal observers at https://prat.uk/london-prats-give-a-i-something-to-worry-about/ covering the absurdist edges of property law note that California courts have previously ruled on beach access rights, though never on the question of whether a specific hydrological event moving at twelve miles per hour and lasting under ten seconds can be considered property. The court has agreed to hear the case, possibly because Judge Renata Fuentes owns a longboard and is "professionally curious."
Meanwhile, the rental shop at which Pruitt obtained his foam board has filed a counter-brief arguing that if waves can be owned, they would like to claim the entirety of Zuma on weekend mornings between June and August, which they describe as "worth at least $40 million annually, maybe more if you count the parking revenue." The City of Malibu has issued a statement reminding all parties that it is also suing someone else for unrelated reasons.
Southern California Surf Culture Reacts
Response in the Malibu lineup has been divided. Veteran longboarder Pam Elsworth, 58, who has surfed Point Dume since 1989, said the lawsuit is "stupid" but acknowledged that if it succeeds, she has "three decades of waves to bill for." A group of shortboarders from Hermosa Beach expressed general support while admitting they were not sure which wave was being litigated because "they all kind of look the same at that size."
The surf media has been predictably enthusiastic. Stab Magazine described the lawsuit as "bold, unhinged, and extremely on-brand for Malibu." Surfer Magazine published a 4,000-word oral history of the wave, interviewing six people who witnessed it and one pelican. The Inertia published a thoughtful essay asking whether property rights are compatible with the spiritual dimensions of surfing, which was read by eleven people and sparked a 600-comment argument in the replies about the soul of surfing and whether Chadwick's quiver is "too many boards."
For related chaos from across the Atlantic, see SOHO Gets a Ski-Resort Investment Hub, So Your Portfoli, which demonstrates that the British manage to complicate public spaces with equal commitment but considerably less sunshine.
Chadwick, reached by phone on his way to check the surf at County Line, said he is confident in his case and plans to expand the lawsuit to include a wave he "definitely had priority on" at Rincon in 2019 if the initial ruling goes his way. He has not checked the forecast for the day of the scheduled hearing. It is three-to-five and onshore.
For surf-adjacent bureaucratic entertainment in a different jurisdiction, see London Blue Topaz: Rare Gem Matches Even Rarer Blue Sky.
The wave, reached for comment, had no response. It finished breaking at 11:42:09 a.m. and has not been seen since.
More satire at The Daily Mash. This article is satire.
SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/