Atlanta United's Dark Curse and Supernatural Mysteries

Atlanta United

The Curse of the Five Stripes: A True Crime Mystery in Atlanta Soccer

In the heart of the South, where passion for sports runs as deep as the Chattahoochee, Atlanta United FC emerged as a Major League Soccer sensation. The club’s rapid rise—an MLS Cup in just its second season, record-breaking crowds, and a fervent fanbase—made it the envy of the league. But behind the dazzling success, whispers began to swirl of a darker force at play. Some called it bad luck. Others believed it was something far more sinister: The Curse of the Five Stripes.

The Rise and the Fall

Atlanta United’s early dominance under coach Tata Martino and star players like Josef Martínez and Miguel Almirón seemed unstoppable. But after their 2018 championship, cracks appeared. Key departures, baffling injuries, and a revolving door of coaches left fans questioning: Was this just the natural ebb and flow of sports… or was there something else at work?

The First Omen

In 2019, during a critical playoff match against Toronto FC, Josef Martínez—the team’s talisman—collapsed with a devastating ACL tear. The injury came just days after a bizarre incident at Mercedes-Benz Stadium: a black cat, an omen of bad luck in many cultures, was seen darting across the pitch during warmups. Stadium staff dismissed it as a stray, but superstitious supporters wondered—was this the first sign of a curse?

The Hex Deepens

Strange occurrences piled up:

The Lockdown Slump – During the pandemic-shortened 2020 season, Atlanta suffered its worst-ever finish. Players later admitted feeling an 'unseen weight' during home games.

The Disappearing Captain – In 2021, star defender Miles Robinson, fresh off a stellar USMNT performance, suffered a torn Achilles in a seemingly routine play.

The Phantom Whistle – In a 2022 match against Austin FC, players froze, believing they heard a referee’s whistle—only for the opposition to score a controversial winner. Replays showed no whistle was blown.

The Supporter’s Secret

Rumors spread among the fanbase. Some pointed to the demolition of the Atlanta-Fulton County Stadium, where the Braves once played, as disturbing sacred ground. Others whispered about a disgruntled former employee who allegedly placed a hex on the team after a bitter departure. The most chilling theory? That the curse was tied to the club’s original mascot, King Arthur, whose sword—a symbol of victory—had been 'broken' in a promotional stunt gone wrong.

Breaking the Curse?

In 2023, under new coach Gonzalo Pineda, signs of revival emerged. A young core led by Thiago Almada and Giorgos Giakoumakis began to turn the tide. But true crime aficionados and paranormal investigators alike wondered: Had the curse truly lifted… or was it merely lying in wait?

As Atlanta United marches forward, one question lingers in the shadows of The Benz: Was their downfall just a run of bad luck, or did something—or someone—put a dark spell on the Five Stripes?

Only time (and perhaps an exorcism) will tell.

🔎 Case Unsolved.
Do you believe in the Curse of the Five Stripes? Or is Atlanta’s story just another tale of sports’ cruel twists of fate?

Atlanta United's Dark Curse and Supernatural Mysteries

Report Page