Mom's Stokke Picks Of The Season Life on the Move Mustela Gentle Cleansing Gel Hair & Body 500ml Aromababy Barrier Balm (25g & 100g) Jellycat bashful tulip pink bunny (More sizes available) California Baby Calendula Cream (2 sizes available) Lassig 4Kids Trolley & Washbag (Designs available) Kushies Cleanbib Fuchsia Modern Flowers (2 sizes available) BToys Jungle Jam Instruments Melissa & Doug ABC-123 Abacus Cambrass Small Nursing Pillow Living Textiles Chevron Blanket IS THIS JUST A CHAIR OR NOT? Latest legal news in Japan and overseas and client alerts to keep you up to date on critical issues. For Legal Updates relating to IP in General, Copyright, Unfair Competition, Plant Variety Protection, etc., please select “Intellectual Property.” Attorney at Law of the Law Division One morning, before going to my office, I was working on an unfinished legal update whilst sitting in a chair. My 5-year old son said “Daddy, don’t sit in my chair.
“Good point I am thinking! This is just a chair, isn’t it?” “What are you saying daddy?” he replied. I believed that this was just a chair but the Intellectual Property High Court of Japan did not think so. The 2015 IP High Court case Stokke v. Katoji involved Stokke’s children’s chair “TRIPP TRAPP.” In this case, Stokke sued Katoji for copyright infringement in part since they sold competing high chair products. The IP High Court ruled that Stokke’s TRIPP TRAPP is copyrightable under Japanese Copyright Law. This was a shocking decision for practitioners including me, and almost made me fall out of my son’s chair when I heard about it.Stokke v. Katoji, Intellectual Property High Court, April 14, 2015, Hei 26 (ne) No. 10063.) Before this decision, Japanese courts including the first instance decision in Stokke v. Katoji at the Tokyo District Court tended to deny copyrightability of industrial designs particularly 3-dimensional designs such as chairs, since it was considered necessary to harmonize protection between Copyright and Design Laws.
Courts used to set a standard that applied arts, which mean useful articles industrially applied, can be copyrightable if they are viewed equivalent to fine arts or works of artistic craftsmanship, which was practically a high hurdle to clear.Stokke v. Katoji, Tokyo District Court, April 17, 2014, Hei 25 (wa) No. 8040. However, the Stokke decision held that “there is no reasonable reason to limit a finding of copyrightability for applied arts on the ground of a protection by Design Law.” If an applied art has originality, for qualifying copyright protection, then it is copyrightable, the IP High Court observed. In conclusion however, the Stokke decision denied copyright infringement because the Katoji products are not similar to the TRIPP TRAPP. Having said that, the Stokke decision would significantly affect our practice since every industrial product could be copyrightable if they are deemed to have originality under the Copyright Law, which is usually a low threshold.
This means that a copyright holder can assert copyright infringement even if another photographed the copyrighted product. The copyright holder can argue copyright infringement if another produced a slavish copy of the product even though the copyright holder has no design registration under the Design Law. This would especially work from 3 years after the first sale since the Unfair Competition Prevention Act prohibits the production of slavish copies of a product design for 3 years from the first sale in Japan. I wonder if the Stokke decision will become a predominant stance of courts in the future. Only time will tell, but nevertheless, we have to know about this decision at least.Unfair Competition Prevention Act, article. 1, no. 3 and article. Next morning, during our breakfast, I asked my son sitting in the TRIPP TRAPP, “Is this just a chair or not?” My son answered in a confident tone, “Daddy, this is my chair.” I thought then that he might one day become a lawyer because his analysis was the same as mine.
General Corporate Cross-border Practices Intellectual Property Patents Designs Trademarks Other legal updates authored by KIMURA, Kodai Legal updates on Intellectual Property Return to search resultsThe Mother&Baby Awards bring you the best of the best - all your essential baby and toddler products, tested by our army of real mums who put everything through its paces just like you will. If you are looking to buy anything for your little one, be sure to check out our Gold, Silver and Bronze Award winners before you make your decisions! Gold: Cosatto Giggle 2Silver: ABC Design MambaBronze: UPPAbaby Vista 2015Gold: UPPAbaby Cruz 2015Silver: Baby Jogger City Mini ZipBronze: Stokke TrailzGold: BumpriderSilver: Out 'n' About Nipper Double V4Bronze: UPPAbaby Vista 2015Gold: Babyzen YoYoSilver: Mamas & Papas Armadillo XTBronze: Out 'n' About Little NipperGold: Britax KING II ATSSilver: BeSafe Combi X4Bronze: Joie™ Stages®Gold: CYBEX Cloud QSilver: Maxi-Cosi Pebble PlusBronze: Joie i-GemmGold: Ella’s Kitchen ‘six months’ rangeSilver
: Organix Goodies Chunky Fruit BarsBronze: HiPP Organic stage 1 pouchesGold: Medela Swing MaxSilver: Ameda Purely Your Lactaline Double Electric BreastpumpBronze: Lansinoh 2 in 1 Double Electric Breast PumpA joint Gold Award for these two products - both scored so highly that we couldn't separate them! Gold: Medela Swing Essentials PackGold: Philips Avent Comfort Single Electric Breast PumpBronze: NUK Luna Electric Breast PumpGold: Brother Max Complete Weaning SetSilver: Munchkin Miracle™ 360° Trainer CupBronze: Vital Baby 8 piece Start Weaning KitGold: Cosatto Noodle Supa HighchairSilver: Stokke StepsBronze: Stokke Tripp TrappGold: MAM Breast Feeding & Steriliser SetSilver: Medela HarmonyBronze: Lansinoh Manual Breast PumpGold: MAM 260ml Anti Colic Bottles 4pkSilver: Philips Avent Classic+ Anti-Colic Feeding BottleBronze: tommee tippee closer to nature Black Perfect Prep MachineGold: Lansinoh HPA LanolinSilver: Lorna Drew Nursing Lingerie The Grace Nursing BraBronze: Lansinoh Disposable Nursing PadsGold: Lansinoh HPA LanolinSilver: Love Boo Mummy skincare rangeBronze: Vichy LiftActiv SupremeGold: Cake Lingerie Cotton Candy seamless nursing braSilver: lights by TENA Liner 24Bronze: Tesco Maternity TowelsGold: BT Video Baby Monitor 7500 LightshowSilver: BT Baby Monitor 350 LightshowBronze
: Summer Infant Baby Touch EdgeGold: Tesco Bath and Room ThermometerSilver: Angelcare Soft-Touch Bath SupportBronze: Munchkin White Hot™ Inflatable Safety Duck BathGold: BabaBing! LoBo2Silver: Fisher-Price Rainforest Friends Take-Along Swing & SeatBronze: BabyBjorn Bouncer Balance SoftGold: Kiddicare Woodhouse Sleigh Cotbed WhiteSilver: Boori Dawn ExpandableBronze: Knuma Huddle 4 in 1 Bedside CribGold: Silentnight Safe Nights Memory Wool MattressSilver: Suncrest Jolly Jamboree Bedding BaleBronze: NightyNite Easychange Supreme Cot MattressGold: Charlie Banana 2-in-1 Swim Diaper and Training Pants with SnapsSilver: LumiPottiBronze: HUGGIES Pull-UpsGold: Mamia Swim PantsSilver: Tesco Loves Baby Newborn NappiesBronze: Halilit Taf Toys Musical Sleepy PalsGold: Tesco Loves Baby Bath and Room ThermometerSilver: Brother Max 2-in-1 ThermometerBronze: Boots Pharmaceuticals Non-Contact ThermometerGold: The Little Green Sheep Organic Mattress ProtectorSilver: The Cuddle Company Patchwork Cuddle BlanketBronze: Silentnight Safe Nights Memory Wool MattressGold: Toys 'R' Us Bruin Deluxe Activity WalkerSilver: Fisher-Price Smart Stages PuppyBronze: Early Learning Centre Drop and Pop GiraffeGold: Sophie la giraffeSilver
: MAM Teething FriendsBronze: Tiny Love Gymini Kick & PlayGold: Micro Scooters Mini Micro ScooterSilver: George Wooden Dolls HouseBronze: Strider 12 Sport Balance BikeGold: Mumma Love Organics Natural Baby SkincareSilver: Asda Little Angels Extra Care SkincareBronze: Childs FarmGold: Morrisons Little Big Mild as Water Newborn WipesSilver: Mamia Baby Wipes Sensitive - Fragrance FreeBronze: Asda Little Angels Extra Protection baby wipesGold: Mamia Newborn NappiesSilver: Mamia Ultra-Dry NappiesBronze: just4bums Mini Disposable Nappies (Size 2)Gold: Bambino Mio miosolo all-in-one nappySilver: TotsBots EasyfitBronze: Pop-in New Gen V2 nappyGold: Ergobaby 360 Bundle of JoySilver: Caboo NCTBronze: LittleLife Adventurer Child CarrierGold: Lässig Green Label Neckline BagSilver: OiOi Eclipse Dot ToteBronze: Skip Hop Duo Special EditionGold: Trunki Made for MeSilver: Chicco LullagoBronze: SnoozeShade Plus DeluxeGold: The Gro Company Travel GrobagSilver: Splash About Anti Bacterial Changing MatBronze