The federal Competition Bureau is investigating whether Canada’s two major department-store retailers have touted bogus discounts of their mattresses.Last month the bureau stepped up its inquiry into Sears Canada Inc. and Hudson’s Bay Co. sale pricing and the Federal Court has agreed to order the merchants to produce records about their price strategies within 75 days. The bureau alleges the retailers “failed to offer certain sleep sets at the regular price or higher for a substantial period of time” and “made materially false or misleading representations to the public in relation to its clearance sales” of mattress sets, according to documents filed in court.Sears got caught about a decade ago for pitching false discounts on tires. Now the bureau is looking at mattress-set prices at Sears and Hudson’s Bay, demanding information on pricing and profit margins in a probe that could turn the estimated $1.8-billion-a year mattress-and-bed foundation business on its head.
Spokespersons for Sears and Hudson’s Bay said they’re co-operating with the investigation and are in the process of providing the information required under the court orders.Sears “is committed to ensuring its advertising makes only valid claims and otherwise meets all legal and regulatory requirements,” said Sears’ spokesman Vincent Power. He added the retailer welcomes “the opportunity to work with the bureau to establish best marketing practices that are applicable to the mattress supply industry.”Hudson’s Bay’s Tiffany Bourre said the country’s mattress retail segment is “highly competitive … Promotional pricing is common within the mattress retail industry.” She said the retailer’s process of pricing its mattresses “is in line with industry standards and, in its view, is in accordance with all Canadian laws and regulations.”Mattress retailing is an opaque sector in which it’s almost impossible for consumers to compare prices among merchants. Retailers tend to carry their own models with their own prices.
But many of the products are made by the industry’s two dominant manufacturers: Tempur Sealy International Inc. and Serta Simmons Bedding LLC.“There’s continual promotion among brands, and products look very similar,” said John Williams of retail consultancy J.C. Williams Group, which estimates 2013 mattress and foundation sales rose 3.6 per cent to $1.8-billion from a year earlier. “The continual sales are confusing. You never know whether you got the best deal.”Still, mattress retailers can generate high profit margins without the risk of having to stock much inventory, shipping products to customers directly from manufacturers, he said.Production is mostly done domestically to avoid costly overseas shipping of the bulky merchandise, said Ryan Trainer, president of the International Sleep Products Association in Alexandria, Va. Mattress companies have efficient “just in time” deliveries of customer purchases – often in just a few days compared to as many as 12 weeks in the furniture business, he said.
The bureau has clamped down on retailers for misleading sale prices in the past. In 2005, the Competition Tribunal ruled that Sears Canada promoted bogus tire prices in ads, resulting in a $100,000 administrative penalty and $387,000 in costs. Less than a year earlier, sporting goods retailer Forzani Group Ltd. (now owned by Canadian Tire Corp. Ltd.) agreed to pay $1.7-million to settle allegations it misled consumers about prices. And in 2003, clothier Suzy Shier Inc. agreed to pay a $1-million penalty in a similar matter.Today the bureau is seeking records from Sears and Hudson’s Bay going back to 2013, court documents say. The bureau’s inquiry found the retailers touted some of their mattress sets for sale at reduced prices for more than half of the time in a six-month period, the filings say. They allege there appears to be examples of the retailers offering mattress sets for sale for longer than a year.The bureau says it has reason to believe the retailers “did not sell a substantial volume of some sleep sets at the regular price or higher for a substantial period of time before making representations about the regular price,” according to the documents.
And they “did not offer sleep sets at the regular price or a higher price in good faith,” the filings say.ForthehomeMasterbedroomsBedroomideasHomesweethome3/4 BedsBeds MattressesHome IdeasCabin IdeasDiy IdeasForwardlayering bedding (this makes me tired, but it sure looks beautiful!)FREE Shipping on orders $49+! Additional 20% off $50+ or Additional 15% off Under $49.99 on Clothing, Accessories, and Fine Jewelry. Receive $5 off purchases $50+. Receive an additional 20% off $35+ Shoes purchases. Save an additional 10% off Women's Watches from Deal Leaf & Free Shipping. Get an additional 10% off Watches Already Up to 20% off. 15% off up to $49.99 Apparel, Accessories & more. Extra 20% off $50 or more Apparel, Accessories & more. Take an additional $25 off $499+ purchase of Kenmore Appliance. Get an additional $35 off $300+ purchase. Get 20% off any in-home Appliance Repair. Visit the Deal Center to find great savings for Sears stores.
Up to 60% off Window Curtains featuring Summit and Jillian Window Panels $9.99. Up to 25% off Small Kitchen Appliances & Members Get Points. 30-50% off Pillows & Mattress Pads. Up to 60% off ALL Luggage.25-50% Off Must Have Tools. Up to 50% off Laura Scott Collection for Her. Up to 80% off Fashion Clearance. Up to 30% off the Home + Members Get $20 Back in Points on a qualifying order of $60+. 20% off Delta Children Furniture. Up to 50% off Simply Emma Plus Fashions. All Futons on sale featuring Madison Cupholder Futon $199.99 on sale. Roebuck & Co Jeans For Him starting at $19.99.60% off Serta Perfect Sleeper Harrowby Mattresses with prices starting at $399.99. Up to 40% off Handbags.Up to 30% off Bed & Bath. Up to 30% off Lighting and Decor. Up to 30% off Craftsman & Gladiator Garage Storage. Up to 50% off Fry Pans and Skillets. Up to 30% off Electronics. Over 30% off featured Fitness Equipment & Special Financing.
Up to 50% off Outdoor Life For Him. Toughskins Mix & Match for Toddlers starting at $5.99.Forecast Blomberg Kodiak 20, 24 or 28 Spinner Collection $59.99 on sale.Simply Styled Clothing for the Family Under $20. Up to 20% off Dinnerware from Gibson and Corelle & other Tableware on sale. Up to 50% off Area and Accent Rugs. 35-50% off Mechanics Tools & Wrenches. 65% off Tradition Diamond Bridal Jewelry. 25% off or more on select Home Gyms. Up to 30% off Sheets. 20% off Lolli Living and Living Textiles Baby Bedding and Decor. Kenmore Small Kitchen Appliances and Cookware starting at $19.99. Semi Annual Lingerie Sale. Up to 40% off Bras & Panties. Save up to 25% on Line Trimmers & Free Shipping $49+. Get 15-50% off Hundreds of Tools. Take an additional 5% off Tractor Attachments Already Up to 20% off. Save up to 20% on Craftsman Tillers & Free Shipping & Delivery. 30% off Home & Members Get $20 Back in Points on a Qualifying Home purchase $60+.
Free Delivery on all Craftsman Pro Series Riding Mowers & Tractors. Additional 5% off or 18 Months No Interest on Featured Craftsman Riding Mowers & Tractors. Receive up to 75% off Top Discounts in Fine Jewelry. Save 20% off Regular priced Thule Bike Racks. Up to 25% Craftsman Riding Mowers & Tractors. Save up to 25% on Craftsman Lawn & Garden. Receive up to 90% off closeout Fine Jewelry. Take an additional 5% off or 12 Months No Interest on Lawn & Garden items $299+ with Sears Card. Take up to $100 off Craftsman & Craftsman Pro Lawn Mowers & Free Shipping. Save up to 30% on Craftsman Sheds & Outdoor Storage & Free Delivery $599+. Save 40-50% off Craftsman Tool Storage Discounts. Up to 90% off Clearance Fine Jewelry. Up to 75% off Top Deals in Fine Jewelry.15-50% off Hundreds of Tools. Up to 30% off Home + Members get $20 Back in Points on a qualifying home order $60+. 3/11 - Online Only. 40-50% off Craftsman Tool Storage Sale.
Save 15% off DieHard Batteries & Members Earn Points. Get 25% off LG Styler Steam Clothing Care System & Free Delivery. 15% off DieHard Batteries & Members Earn Points. Receive $100 off select Electrolux Washer & Dryer Pairs & Free Delivery. Save an additional 10% off Cooper, Guardsman or Uniroyal Tires at Sears Auto. Up to 700,000 back in points on select KitchenAid Appliances. Save 15-50% off Must Have Tools. Buy LG Signature 4 Piece Laundry Bundle, Get $500 Rebate & Free Delivery. Free Shipping purchases $49+. Save on Kids' Apparel. Shop Baby and Kids. Shop Furniture and Mattresses. Shop Fitness and Sporting Goods. Shop Bed, Bath and Home. Shop Toys and Outdoor Play. Get exclusive offers & updates when you sign up for the Sears email list. Get Free Shipping on Sears Gift Cards. Shop the Auto Department. Shop the Hot Weekly Deal. See the Sears Price Match Guarantee. Join Shop Your Way Rewards to earn points on all your Sears purchases.
15% off Edwards Big & Tall Wool Blend Flat Front Dress Pant - Online exclusive, Men's, Size: 48x30, Dark Grey. Take $13 off Edwards Big & Tall Wool Blend Flat Front Dress Pant - Online exclusive, Men's, Size: 50x36, Blue. $9 off Wrangler Men's Cowboy Cut Jeans - Original Fit, Size: 36x30, Shadow Black. Save 21% on Wrangler Men's Cowboy Cut Jeans - Slim Fit, Size: 30x32, Stone Wash. $7 off Edwards Big & Tall Blended Chino Pleated Pant - Online Exclusive, Men's, Size: 54x28, Blue. Take $31 off Bulwark Premium Coverall - Excel FR ComforTouch - 9 oz, Men's, Size: 56, Blue. 21% off LEE Men's Relaxed Fit Straight Leg Jeans, Size: 34x32, Light Blue. $9 off Wrangler Men's Cowboy Cut Jeans - Slim Fit, Size: 32x36, Black. Save 16% on LEE No Iron Men's Pleated Pant, Size: 38x32, Green. Save 21% on Wrangler Men's Cowboy Cut Jeans - Original Fit, Size: 36x34, Shadow Black. Save 40% on Dockers Men's Cool Effects Easy Khaki, D3 Classic Fit Flat Front Pants, Size: 38x29, Grey.