For over 130 years, the Sealy brand has been synonymous with comfort, quality, and support for every kind of sleeper. With award-winning crib mattresses and innovative crib bedding, families trust Sealy Baby to give their baby the very best. For over 130 years, Sealy sleep products have been synonymous with comfort, quality, support and the latest technology to bring great rest to every kind of sleeper. With award-winning crib mattresses, innovative crib bedding, plus beautiful cribs and nursery furniture, families trust Sealy Baby to bring safety and style home.Last updated: May 5, 2016. Best Crib Mattress: Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic Lightweight crib mattress—it’s a mouthful, but the name really says it all: this mattress is lightweight; organic and GREENGUARD certified. Worried about crib mattress safety? Wondering which mattress is right for you? Check out Crib Mattresses 101. Perfect for first-time parents and even old hands who need a refresher.
We evaluate crib mattresses with hands-on inspections, reviews by our readers and online feedback. We do not accept free samples from manufacturers—if we purchase a mattress to review, we buy it from the same sources we recommend on this site (Amazon, stores, etc). We also meet manufacturers in person at trade events and evaluate product samples and prototypes. We have been researching and writing about crib mattresses since 1994. With the advent of new foams and cover materials as well as interest in organic and natural mattresses, the options have greatly expanded for new parents. Our PickNaturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic Lightweight27.5″ x 52″ x 6Naturepedic’s No Compromise Organic Cotton Lightweight Classic mattress incorporates all the features we’re looking for in a crib mattress: light weight, no chemicals, waterproof cover, organic fabrics. $258.00* at Amazon* Prices change daily. Naturepedic’s owner Barry Cik got the idea for his company after a frustrating search for a crib mattress for his grandchild.
Cik, an environmental engineer and hazardous material expert, was appalled at what he found on the market—crib mattresses made of petro-chemical foam, chemical fire retardants and more. “I knew all about vinyl/PVC, polyurethane foam, and the various chemicals contained in them and there was no way I was going to put my grandchild to sleep within a few inches of these chemicals” Cik said. In 2004, Cik launched Naturepedic as a more natural alternative. The company has five goals for its crib mattresses: no harmful chemicals; natural, organic and renewable materials wherever possible; practical, easy to clean design; and third-party testing by GreenGuard to ensure they meet strict standards. Naturepedic offers four series of crib mattresses: lightweight, classic, ultra and quilted/2-in-1. Prices range from $260 to $289. The No Compromise Organic Cotton Lightweight Classic mattress is uniquely designed with closed-cell air pockets made from food-grade polyethylene (no polyethylene).
Called Wavesupport, the pockets are created with a wave design as shown below: Here’s an actual photo of the Wavesupport as well: As a result, this mattress is half the weight of a traditional coil mattress. The cover is organic cotton fabric with a food grade polyethylene waterproof—making it both waterproof and dust mite/bed bug proof. Under the cover is another layer of organic cotton filling and there are no chemicals required to make it flame retardant. Another plus, the mattress is seamless with waterproof edges. The No Compromise is GREENGUARD certified and the components are certified organic as well. This is Naturepedic’s best-selling model at $260; a dual-firmness model is $300. While these prices may seem high compared to other crib mattresses, it is substantially less than the competition in the organic mattress category. See below under Crib Mattress Competition. If you want a coil mattress, Naturepedic’s Organic Cotton Classic 150 coil mattress is our pick at $260.
It’s made with organic cotton filling, a firm coil innerspring and the waterproof cover mentioned above. The No Compromise is not exactly the cheapest mattress on the market, but it is comparable (and somewhat less expensive than) other organic, chemical free options. In online reviews, some parents have complained their mattress sagged after only a short time. Other parents note that the measurement of the mattress was off and it was too small for their crib (leaving an unacceptable gap). Naturepedic replaced those mattresses that had problems. Overall, the company’s customer service is good. Also GreatLullaby Earth Super Lightweight$169.00* at Amazon* Prices change daily. Lullaby Earth’s Super Lightweight mattress is a great option if you have a bit more money to spend. It is made of polyethylene foam (a non-toxic, food-grade foam that requires no fire retardant chemicals) and weighs just 6.5 lbs. Most other foam mattresses on the market are made of polyurethane.
It features seamless edges and Greenguard-certification. Lullaby Earth’s Super Lightweight crib mattress is a good deal at $169—and Lullaby Earth is the more affordable division of Naturepedic. Same quality and environmental commitment. “All natural” crib mattresses similar to the No Compromise mattress include those made by Naturalmat, Greenbuds Baby, Natura, and Nook. Many of them are more expensive than the Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton ($400 and up in most cases), while others are missing key features like a waterproof cover (Natura and Nook, for example). Naturepedic’s No Compromise Organic Cotton Lightweight Classic mattress incorporates all the features we’re looking for in a crib mattress: light weight, waterproof cover, organic fabrics. Compared to other organic mattresses that top $400, the Naturepedic No Compromise at $258 is a decent buy. Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic Lightweight27.5″ x 52″ x 6Naturepedic’s No Compromise Organic Cotton Lightweight Classic mattress incorporates all the features we’re looking for in a crib mattress: light weight, no chemicals, waterproof cover, organic fabrics.