Reports #2
Yuri Panarin for Telegram IV ContestThis list was originally submitted by Yuri Panarin in this appeal. It has been moved to this page to lock its contents from ongoing edits.
STATUS: DONE
25.
- Duplicate of title before main content (on original page it’s a link to current article, now its not a link - just useless text)
- Missed author name which is clearly shown on the page (Olivier Lascar). Block with author’s name has specific class and can be easily detected.
Admin's comment: the missing link is a G4 issue. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/sciencesetavenir.fr/template10/issue2/
The suggested author issue would've been accepted had there been a template that could prove that it is possible to reliably parse this.
_________________________________________________________
26.
IV generated for contact page with lot of interactions (Grade 2).
Admin's comment: True. Both templates had to be rejected. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/footballchannel.jp/template7/issue1/ and https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/footballchannel.jp/template8/issue1/
________________________________________________________
27.
Missing JS navigation in slideshows, now it’s just a single photo instead of JS-slideshow (Grade 1)
Admin's comment: Indeed. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/24h.com.vn/template7/issue2/
________________________________________________________
28.
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/sport-express.ru/template13/issue1/
Same situations, different decisions. I think, both of them must be in contest or declined if its really critical issue.
Admin's comment: Correct. This template has already been rejected following a report from a different source. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/anninhthudo.vn/template8/issue1/
____________________________________________________________
29.
- Missing date
- Missing figcaptions
- Banner at bottom of page
- Looks like action.nova.cz subdomain is not supported
Admin's comment: The first three are valid issues. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/nova.cz/template4/issue1/
Number 4 is a G7 and would not have been sufficient to reject the template in the absence of an alternative that supports this well.
_________________________________________________________
30.
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/drive.ru/template21/issue1/
Second fully support all page with tables, it looks perfect, why it doesnt win? Thank you, it’s just an interest of lot participants.
Admin's comment: This visual graph is much more informative than a column of numbers — you can say how much the numbers change and what's the step merely by glancing at the curve. IV currently doesn't posses any means for creating a similar experience. One could even argue that the version from template 22 constitutes a G5 issue of medium severity. Not supporting this page should be the preferred solution and is definitely not an issue.
_________________________________________________________
31.
This page contains a single photo gallery. Unfortunately, this template doesn't format it according to 6.4. (https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-galleries-and-slideshows)
Admin's comment: Sad, but true. This template is otherwise superior to template #7 in every respect. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/spin.ph/template4/issue2/
_________________________________________________________
32.
This page contains a single photo gallery. Unfortunately, this template doesn't format it according to 6.4. (https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-galleries-and-slideshows)
Admin's comment: Sad again, but true again. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/kienthuc.net.vn/template5/issue2/ https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/kienthuc.net.vn/template7/issue2/
_________________________________________________________
33.
Missing linebreaks in blockquote. Unreadable text.
Admin's comment: True. The domain will not have a winner in the first contest. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/mel.fm/template10/issue1/ https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/mel.fm/template11/issue1/
_________________________________________________________
34.
Invalid tags in cover figcaptions
AND
Invalid order of images in list (look on list after title “Idaho”)
_________________________________________________________
35.
Missed order of slideshows (both of them replaced to footer, but on original page one of them was in the middle of text - logical structure is lost
AND
Same issue + lot of text between slideshows is missed.
Admin's comment: Both true. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/kurier.at/template6/issue2/
_________________________________________________________
36.
Lost a GIANT part of article (Grade 1)
Admin's comment: True. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/debate.com.mx/template8/issue2/
AND
Unsupported video is lost, must not be generated.
(Look before “Hasta el momento”)
Admin's comment: Also true. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/debate.com.mx/template8/issue3/
_________________________________________________________
37.
Page cant be supported fully(havent unsupported elements)
Admin's comment: Since this domain no longer has any standing templates, this G7 issue is not enough to reject it.
_________________________________________________________
38.
Missing subtitle (G1)
Admin's comment: True. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/sporx.com/template4/issue3/ Although this template wasn't winning the contest anyway.